The following is from Mosi Platt of the Miami Heat Index.
Bloggers from the Wages of Wins Network got together for their regular weekend podcast to discuss the NBA playoffs, Derrick Rose, the Dead Basketball Poets Society, Best (and Worst) Defensive Players of the Year, Sixth Man of the Year as well as the Most (and Least) Improved Players of the Year.
Listeners can enjoy the podcast one of three ways:
- Download it from nerdnumbers.com,
- Subscribe to the RSS feed or
- Check it out at iTunes.
The Cast
- Mosi Platt from the Miami Heat Index
- Andres Alvarez from NerdNumbers.com
The Synopsis
- Platt and Alvarez covered a lot of different topics in this free-flowing discussion. Here’s a rundown of the conversation:
- Alvarez starts the podcast off by comparing the Heat to a killer in a slasher movie and Chris Bosh to J.R. Smith. Yes, it sounds weird.
- A lot of fans complain that stat-heads just focus on the numbers and don’t watch the games. In Alvarez’s case, blame it on the recession or The Matrix. Plus, the pros and cons of NBA League Pass were also discussed.
- The WoW Network bloggers briefly discuss the Blazers-Mavericks series. On Wednesday’s PTI Show, Tony Kornheiser compared Brandon Roy to Penny Hardaway. Both bloggers agreed that it was a good comparison, but the numbers say Penny was more productive than Roy (see the figure below). In addition to being more productive, Penny got to play with a 22 year-old Shaquille O’Neal in the 1995 NBA Finals (even though Shaq dissed him later) and make commercials with Chris Rock before succumbing to knee injuries. Roy, on the other hand, has rarely gotten the chance to play with a 22 year-old Greg Oden and has never advanced past the first round.
- After Blazers-Mavs, the conversation turned to the Bulls-Pacers series, Derrick Rose and the Dead Basketball Poets Society’s myth-making about his exploits. What is the Dead Basketball Poets Society? It’s a group of sportswriters that use lazy cliches to describe what they can’t understand on the court. For example, if the Bulls win despite Derrick Rose shooting 4-18, then they won because of Rose’s “toughness”, “leadership” or “confidence.” In fact, that’s what Charles Barkley and Kenny Smith said on “Inside the NBA.”
- Platt and Alvarez both agreed that Adrian Wojnarowski is a hater, but they had different reasons. This was Platt’s reason and this was Alvarez’s reason.
The podcast ended with a discussion of the Wages of Wins Network Awards, the Anti-Awards and the three Kia Performance Awards the NBA released this week:
- Defensive Player of the Year – Dwight Howard. Platt and Alvarez discussed who should win the Worst Defensive Player of the Year award.
- Sixth Man of the Year – Lamar Odom. Platt said that Marcin Gortat should have gotten more consideration than a ninth-place finish.
- Most Improved Player – Kevin Love. Alvarez suggested Andrea Bargnani should win the Least Improved Player award. Platt’s spreadsheet froze during the podcast, but afterwards he determined that Troy Murphy would be a good nomination, too, with a Win Score that declined by 8.7 points this season.
– Mosi Platt
reservoirgod
April 23, 2011
Thanks for the post, Dave!
AWilliams
April 24, 2011
No professor Berri?
Italian Stallion
April 24, 2011
I’ve become convinced that the average former player, sportswriter, radio call in host, and fan evaluates players to a large extent on what I would call “degree of difficulty exploits”.
If a player can do some things that few other players can, the net of everything he does is worth less than than the difficult things he can do.
That’s why guys like Rose, Kobe, Melo, AI etc.. are held in such high regard and boring high efficiency scorers, that rebound, make plays, limit their turnovers etc… aren’t. People are impressed by athleticism, tough shot making etc… and are essentially clueless about the values.
I’ll go as far as saying that IMO basketball is the least efficient market I have ever been exposed to and I’ve spent decades gambling on horse racing, poker, black jack, stocks, options, bonds, and now sports. Basketball is like taking candy from a baby compared to those other games.
EntityAbyss
April 24, 2011
I’m about to check the podcast, but according to this, you guys didn’t discuss Chris Paul’s domination of the lakers to this point. What’s up with that? Best point guard.
Jim Glass
April 25, 2011
Not exactly on topic, but Melo is mentioned above, and two broadcasts about today’s Knicks-Celtics game can maybe supplement the podcast…
The network game analysts at half-time, sort of in shock about horribly the Knicks had played to be down 55-38 at the half…
“… and, somehow, Carmelo passes for being ‘on fire’ with 19 first-half points — on 5 of 13 shooting…”
The 11 o’clock news sports report…
“The Knicks’ season came to a close today. But nobody can blame the Pride of the Knicks, Carmelo Anthony, who had 19 points in the first half alone!”
reservoirgod
May 2, 2011
Everybody loves the backup QB but nobody loves the backup podcasters…